Forum

Teaching Students the Steps of assessing sources

3 Posts
3 Users
2 Reactions
106 Views
(@melissa-jenkins)
Trusted Member
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 32
Topic starter  

I looked at three posters/worksheets that used acronyms or s step-by-step flow chart to take students through the steps of assessing news sources:

S.E.E.D.: To detect propaganda, look for simplification, exploitation, exaggeration, and division.

E.S.C.A.P.E.: Evidence, Source, Context, Audience, Purpose, Execution

"Consumers Questions": Who, Why, How, When, What, Where

I really liked the consumers questions because they are familiar to me and probably many of us as "journalist" questions. It seems easier to remember than "Seed" and "Escape" and mirrors the questions students could ask themselves as they read media content AND as they conduct their own research to create media content. I also like the invitation to think of the journalist as another "consumer" - that the journalist perspective is in some ways similar to the reader's perspective. They are trying to piece the story together from the outside as well. We can assess their work and also do "journalistic" work of our own.

I teach a lot of first-year and extension school writing as well as upper-level classes for English majors and MA students at the college level.

I also like how "Consumers Questions" feel more neutral than the acronyms asking them to "Weed" out bad information or "Escape" bad information. I like the idea of going in with a neutral sense of exploration rather than automatic suspicion. Some sources may be better than we expect, and we don't want people to be afraid to try.


   
Quote
(@marie-himes)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 18
 

Hi Melissa,

Β 

Thank you for your thoughtful feedback on my LP!Β 

Β 

I find that heuristics can be powerful learning tools in my work with K-12 students. The source credibility evaluation framework that I'm most familiar with is CRAAP (which elicits a lot of snickers from middle and high schoolers 😊 ) and stands for Currency.Relevance.Authority.Accuracy.Purpose.

Β 

Your perspective on the "Consumer Questions" framework resonates with me; employing this approach to news source assessment as consumers and then as news creators underscores the robustness of this heuristic.

Β 

One of the greatest challenges that I have in supporting students' assessment of news sources is identifying what is not mentioned or is missing from a piece of media in terms of related/connected content/context and thinking through/inferring why that information was left out.

Β 

Look forward to connecting with you throughout the course!

Β 

With gratitude,

Marie


   
ReplyQuote
(@sasha-elias)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 14
 

Thank you for your sharing that framework of consumer questions. I agree that it will be accessible and easy to remember when working with students. I think it's a great way to build on pre-existing language that students are already familiar with!


   
ReplyQuote